The Heritage Foundation's Review of Kowalczyk and an Out-of-Control State Supreme Court
If you live in California or have been following the ongoing daytime drama of "Bail" in the state, then you have most likely heard of a recent Supreme Court case referred to as Kowalczyk
If you live in California or have been following the ongoing daytime drama of "Bail" in the state, then you have most likely heard of a recent Supreme Court case referred to as Kowalczyk. The controversial findings in this case are no surprise to anyone who has lived through the California Supreme Court's history of wild misinterpretations of the state constitution.
In a November 2026 Legal Memorandum, Charles Stimson of The Heritage Foundation criticizes the California Supreme Court’s April 2026 decision in In re Kowalczyk. The court held that, except in capital cases, the California Constitution guarantees defendants a right to pretrial release on bail and requires judges to set any monetary bail at an amount that is “reasonably attainable” by the accused. Stimson argues this creates a judge-made entitlement that overrides the text, history, and structure of the state constitution, downplays risks to victims and the public, and ignores repeated voter decisions.
The memorandum places the ruling in a longer pattern of the California Supreme Court expanding criminal defendants’ rights, followed by voter corrections. It reviews Propositions 4 and 8 (1982), which limited when judges must grant bail and prioritized public safety; Proposition 189 (1994); and Marsy’s Law (Proposition 9, 2008), which reinforced that public and victim safety must be primary considerations and that judges “may” (not “shall”) release defendants on bail. Stimson contends these amendments cannot be reconciled with the court’s new “reasonably attainable” standard and that the court has repeatedly diminished choices the electorate made.
The piece also examines the practical role of cash bail as a tool that balances pretrial liberty with accountability and public safety, and it criticizes broader efforts to eliminate cash bail. It discusses the failure of Proposition 25 (which would have replaced cash bail with risk assessments), policies adopted by progressive prosecutors such as George Gascón, and the earlier 2021 In re Humphrey decision. Stimson concludes that the Kowalczyk holding is contrary to the constitution as amended by the people and should be corrected by voters or the legislature, reaffirming that the criminal justice system must protect the accused while also safeguarding victims and the public.
Read the full Legal Memorandum here>>>